Fidelity is the best default choice for most long-term investors. Charles Schwab is the best choice for active traders who liked TD Ameritrade, while E*TRADE stands out for paper trading, options analysis and futures tools.
TD Ameritrade is no longer a standalone brokerage. Charles Schwab acquired TD Ameritrade, moved its client accounts to Schwab and added the thinkorswim platform to its brokerage offering.
Quick Comparison
Best overall for most investors
- Best choice
- Fidelity
- Why
- Low-cost mutual funds, fractional shares, no retail brokerage minimums and useful research tools
Best replacement for TD Ameritrade
- Best choice
- Charles Schwab
- Why
- thinkorswim, trading tools, branches and support for stocks, options, futures and forex
Best for active traders who want paper trading
- Best choice
- E*TRADE
- Why
- Power E*TRADE includes paper trading, options analysis, futures ladders and customizable scans
Best for mutual funds and low-cost index investing
- Best choice
- Fidelity
- Why
- Fidelity funds, no-transaction-fee funds and zero-expense-ratio index funds
Best for futures pricing
- Best choice
- E*TRADE
- Why
- Futures commissions are listed at $1.50 per contract, compared with $2.25 at Schwab
Best for fractional-share investing
- Best choice
- Fidelity or Schwab
- Why
- Both support dollar-based investing from $1, with broad eligibility
Best for branch access
- Best choice
- Charles Schwab
- Why
- Schwab offers more than 400 physical branches
| Investor need | Best choice | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Best overall for most investors | Fidelity | Low-cost mutual funds, fractional shares, no retail brokerage minimums and useful research tools |
| Best replacement for TD Ameritrade | Charles Schwab | thinkorswim, trading tools, branches and support for stocks, options, futures and forex |
| Best for active traders who want paper trading | E*TRADE | Power E*TRADE includes paper trading, options analysis, futures ladders and customizable scans |
| Best for mutual funds and low-cost index investing | Fidelity | Fidelity funds, no-transaction-fee funds and zero-expense-ratio index funds |
| Best for futures pricing | E*TRADE | Futures commissions are listed at $1.50 per contract, compared with $2.25 at Schwab |
| Best for fractional-share investing | Fidelity or Schwab | Both support dollar-based investing from $1, with broad eligibility |
| Best for branch access | Charles Schwab | Schwab offers more than 400 physical branches |
What Happened to TD Ameritrade?
TD Ameritrade clients are now Schwab clients. The current comparison is therefore Charles Schwab, the successor to TD Ameritrade, vs E*TRADE vs Fidelity.
Schwab kept the thinkorswim desktop, web and mobile platforms. That makes Schwab the closest modern equivalent to the former TD Ameritrade experience for options traders, technical traders and investors who used thinkorswim.
Fidelity vs Schwab vs E*TRADE: Pricing
All three brokers offer commission-free online trading for U.S.-listed stocks and ETFs. Options trades usually include a per-contract fee, so a $0 stock commission does not make every trade free.
Online U.S.-listed stocks
- Charles Schwab
- $0
- E*TRADE
- $0
- Fidelity
- $0
Online ETFs
- Charles Schwab
- $0
- E*TRADE
- $0
- Fidelity
- $0
Options base commission
- Charles Schwab
- $0
- E*TRADE
- $0
- Fidelity
- $0
Standard options contract fee
- Charles Schwab
- $0.65
- E*TRADE
- $0.65
- Fidelity
- $0.65
Discounted options contract fee
- Charles Schwab
- Not listed as a standard volume discount
- E*TRADE
- $0.50 with at least 30 qualifying trades per quarter
- Fidelity
- May offer negotiated rates for eligible active traders
Futures
- Charles Schwab
- $2.25 per contract
- E*TRADE
- $1.50 per contract
- Fidelity
- Not a core Fidelity brokerage product
Secondary bonds and CDs
- Charles Schwab
- $1 per bond, with minimum and maximum charges
- E*TRADE
- $1 per bond, with minimum and maximum charges
- Fidelity
- $1 per bond
Mutual funds
- Charles Schwab
- Schwab OneSource funds at $0; other funds can cost up to $74.95 per purchase
- E*TRADE
- No-transaction-fee funds at $0
- Fidelity
- Fidelity funds at $0; transaction-fee funds can cost $49.95 per purchase
Account minimum
- Charles Schwab
- $0
- E*TRADE
- $0
- Fidelity
- $0
| Product or fee | Charles Schwab | E*TRADE | Fidelity |
|---|---|---|---|
| Online U.S.-listed stocks | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| Online ETFs | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| Options base commission | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| Standard options contract fee | $0.65 | $0.65 | $0.65 |
| Discounted options contract fee | Not listed as a standard volume discount | $0.50 with at least 30 qualifying trades per quarter | May offer negotiated rates for eligible active traders |
| Futures | $2.25 per contract | $1.50 per contract | Not a core Fidelity brokerage product |
| Secondary bonds and CDs | $1 per bond, with minimum and maximum charges | $1 per bond, with minimum and maximum charges | $1 per bond |
| Mutual funds | Schwab OneSource funds at $0; other funds can cost up to $74.95 per purchase | No-transaction-fee funds at $0 | Fidelity funds at $0; transaction-fee funds can cost $49.95 per purchase |
| Account minimum | $0 | $0 | $0 |
Schwab lists $0 online commissions for listed stocks and ETFs, $0.65 per options contract, $2.25 futures contracts and $0 trades for Schwab Mutual Fund OneSource funds.
ETRADE charges $0 for online U.S.-listed stocks, ETFs, mutual funds and the base options commission. Its standard options contract fee is $0.65, with a $0.50 rate for customers who meet its trading-volume requirement. ETRADE lists futures at $1.50 per contract.
Fidelity charges $0 for online U.S. stock, ETF and options trades, although options contract fees still apply. Fidelity lists $1 secondary-market bond trades, free online U.S. Treasury trades and separate fees for transaction-fee mutual funds.
Which Broker Is Best for Long-Term Investors?
Fidelity is the strongest choice for long-term investors.
Fidelity offers:
- No minimum to open a retail brokerage account
- Fractional shares and dollar-based investing from $1
- Fidelity mutual funds with no transaction fees
- A large selection of outside mutual funds
- Zero-expense-ratio index mutual funds
- Fund screening and research tools
- 24/7 phone support
Fidelity's zero-expense-ratio index funds cover large-cap U.S. stocks, the broader U.S. market, extended-market stocks and international stocks. These funds have no investment minimums, although investors should still review each fund's strategy, diversification and tax characteristics.
Fidelity also provides access to thousands of mutual funds from companies outside Fidelity. Its mutual fund tools let investors filter funds by expense ratio, performance, transaction fees and other criteria.
Why Fidelity Works Well for Buy-and-Hold Investing
For investors who mainly buy index funds, mutual funds, ETFs or fractional shares, fund selection and recurring investing matter more than small differences in trading interfaces.
A $0 stock commission is no longer a major difference between these brokers. Fund costs, account fees, fractional-share access and research tools matter more for a long-term portfolio.
Which Broker Is Best for Active Traders?
Charles Schwab is the best choice for active traders who want the closest successor to TD Ameritrade.
Schwab's main advantage is thinkorswim, which is available on desktop, web and mobile. The platform includes charting, custom scans, trading tools, paperMoney practice trading and market research.
Schwab also supports:
- Stocks and ETFs
- Options
- Futures
- Futures options
- Forex
- Advanced screeners
- Custom indicators and scans
- Real-time research and market data
- Branch-based support
Schwab lists futures commissions at $2.25 per contract and forex trades with no separate commission. Forex costs are reflected in the bid-ask spread.
Schwab Is the Best TD Ameritrade Alternative
Schwab is the better fit for former TD Ameritrade users who want to keep using:
- thinkorswim charting
- Options analysis
- Technical studies
- Paper trading
- Advanced order tools
- Active-trading education
The Schwab website and account structure differ from the former TD Ameritrade setup, but thinkorswim remains the main connection between the two firms.
Which Broker Is Best for Options and Paper Trading?
E*TRADE is the strongest alternative for traders who want paper trading and options-analysis tools.
Power E*TRADE includes:
- Paper trading with virtual money
- Multi-leg options trading
- Options chains with Greeks
- Risk and reward analysis
- Earnings Move Analyzer
- Custom and preset scans
- Advanced charting
- Futures ladders
- Time and sales
- Keyboard shortcuts
E*TRADE's paper-trading environment lets users test strategies without risking real capital. The platform also supports stocks, ETFs, options, futures and options on futures.
E*TRADE suits investors who want more than a basic brokerage app but do not need the full thinkorswim ecosystem.
Fractional Shares: Fidelity vs Schwab vs E*TRADE
All three brokers offer fractional-share investing, but the programs differ.
Fidelity
Fidelity lets investors buy fractional shares of eligible U.S. stocks and ETFs with investments starting at $1. Investors can enter trades by dollar amount or fractional-share quantity.
Charles Schwab
Schwab offers fractional investing in more than 7,000 U.S.-listed stocks and ETFs, with investments starting at $1. The service is available through eligible brokerage accounts and can be used for commission-free online purchases.
E*TRADE
E*TRADE offers fractional shares in eligible listed securities, including select stocks and ETFs. Fractional-share orders can use quantities of up to three decimal places, with a listed minimum trade amount of $5.
Best for fractional investing: Fidelity and Schwab are better choices for investors who want a $1 starting amount and dollar-based investing. E*TRADE remains suitable when its trading platform matters more than its fractional-share minimum.
Which Broker Has the Best Trading Platform?
Best Advanced Platform: Charles Schwab thinkorswim
thinkorswim is the best fit for traders who want detailed charting, technical indicators, custom scans, options tools and a configurable workspace.
Best Paper-Trading Platform: ETRADE Power ETRADE
Power E*TRADE is the better choice for investors who want to practice strategies with simulated money. Its platform also puts options probability, earnings-move and risk-reward analysis within easy reach.
Best Multi-Device Platform: Fidelity Trader+
Fidelity Trader+ is Fidelity's newer active-trading platform for desktop, web and mobile. It includes charting, customizable layouts, real-time data, alerts and trading tools for stocks, ETFs, options and crypto. Fidelity is moving users from its legacy Active Trader Pro platform toward Trader+.
Fidelity is a strong general-purpose brokerage, but Schwab and E*TRADE are better fits for traders focused on technical analysis, rapid order entry or complex options workflows.
Which Broker Is Best for Beginners?
Fidelity is the best choice for most beginners.
Investors can open a Fidelity retail brokerage account without a minimum deposit, buy fractional shares from $1 and use its educational and research tools.
Schwab is also a good choice for beginners who value:
- Physical branches
- 24/7 service
- Educational content
- Paper trading through thinkorswim
- A path toward more advanced trading
Schwab lists more than 400 physical branches and 24/7 service.
E*TRADE fits beginners who want a simple interface and the option to test strategies with paper trading before placing real trades.
Final Verdict
Choose Fidelity when your priorities are long-term investing, retirement accounts, index funds, mutual funds, fractional shares and low ongoing costs.
Choose Charles Schwab when you want the modern replacement for TD Ameritrade, particularly thinkorswim, active trading, options, futures, technical analysis or branch access.
Choose E*TRADE when paper trading, options-analysis tools, futures pricing and an active-trading platform matter most.
For most investors starting from scratch, Fidelity is the best overall pick. Former TD Ameritrade users and serious active traders will usually get more from Charles Schwab.