Charles Schwab is the better choice for most U.S. investors who previously compared TD Ameritrade. Interactive Brokers is better for active traders, margin users, international investors, futures traders and investors who need advanced execution tools.
There is one important change to the comparison: TD Ameritrade is no longer a standalone U.S. brokerage. TD Ameritrade clients are now Charles Schwab clients, and the thinkorswim platform remains available through Schwab.
Both Schwab and Interactive Brokers offer $0 online trading for eligible U.S.-listed stocks and ETFs, so the better choice usually depends on platform design, margin costs, market access and customer support.
Interactive Brokers vs Schwab at a Glance
Beginner-friendly investing
- Winner
- Schwab
- Why
- Simpler experience, strong education and more service options
Active stock and options trading
- Winner
- Tie
- Why
- Schwab has thinkorswim; IBKR offers deeper execution and order controls
Futures trading
- Winner
- Interactive Brokers
- Why
- Lower published commission
Margin borrowing
- Winner
- Interactive Brokers
- Why
- Much lower published margin rates
International markets
- Winner
- Interactive Brokers
- Why
- Access to more markets and currencies
Customer service and branches
- Winner
- Schwab
- Why
- Dedicated trading support and physical branches
Paper trading
- Winner
- Schwab
- Why
- thinkorswim paper trading is included
Automated trading and APIs
- Winner
- Interactive Brokers
- Why
- Strong API, algorithmic tools and trading infrastructure
Retirement and general investing
- Winner
- Schwab
- Why
- Better fit for investors who want a wider U.S. financial-services relationship
| Category | Winner | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Beginner-friendly investing | Schwab | Simpler experience, strong education and more service options |
| Active stock and options trading | Tie | Schwab has thinkorswim; IBKR offers deeper execution and order controls |
| Futures trading | Interactive Brokers | Lower published commission |
| Margin borrowing | Interactive Brokers | Much lower published margin rates |
| International markets | Interactive Brokers | Access to more markets and currencies |
| Customer service and branches | Schwab | Dedicated trading support and physical branches |
| Paper trading | Schwab | thinkorswim paper trading is included |
| Automated trading and APIs | Interactive Brokers | Strong API, algorithmic tools and trading infrastructure |
| Retirement and general investing | Schwab | Better fit for investors who want a wider U.S. financial-services relationship |
Is Interactive Brokers or TD Ameritrade Better?
Choose Charles Schwab if you want an easier all-purpose brokerage with thinkorswim, customer support, paper trading, retirement accounts and branch access. Choose Interactive Brokers if you care most about low margin costs, international markets, futures, foreign exchange, complex order types or API-based trading.
For a typical buy-and-hold investor who buys U.S. stocks and ETFs, the commission difference is usually small. Platform design, market access, margin rates and service matter more.
Fees: Interactive Brokers Is Usually Cheaper for Advanced Trading
Stocks and ETFs
Charles Schwab charges $0 for online listed stock and ETF trades, subject to exclusions such as some over-the-counter securities, transaction-fee mutual funds and broker-assisted trades.
Interactive Brokers offers two main pricing structures:
- IBKR Lite: $0 commission on eligible U.S. exchange-listed stocks and ETFs
- IBKR Pro fixed pricing: $0.005 per share, with a $1 minimum per order
- IBKR Pro tiered pricing: starts at $0.0035 per share, with a $0.35 minimum, before applicable exchange and regulatory fees
For occasional U.S. stock investors, both brokers can be inexpensive. IBKR Pro gives active traders more control over pricing and execution, but its tiered schedule is harder to understand.
Options
Charles Schwab charges $0 base commission plus $0.65 per options contract for standard online options trades.
Interactive Brokers charges:
- IBKR Pro: approximately $0.15 to $0.65 per contract, depending on volume and pricing tier
- IBKR Lite: generally uses fixed pricing for options
- Additional exchange, regulatory, transaction and clearing fees may apply
Verdict: Schwab is easier to price. Interactive Brokers can cost less for high-volume options traders who qualify for lower tiers.
Futures
Interactive Brokers lists U.S. futures commissions starting at $0.85 per contract, plus applicable exchange, regulatory and clearing fees.
Charles Schwab charges $2.25 per futures or futures-options contract, before customary exchange and regulatory fees.
Verdict: Interactive Brokers has the lower published futures commission.
Margin Rates
Interactive Brokers is much cheaper for margin borrowing.
IBKR's published USD margin schedule shows IBKR Pro rates beginning at 5.38% for the first margin tier, while Schwab's smallest standard margin tier is listed at 12.075%. Rates can change, and the actual cost depends on the balance tier and account type.
At those rates:
- Borrowing $25,000 at 5.38% costs about $1,345 in annualized interest before compounding and rate changes.
- Borrowing $25,000 at 12.075% costs about $3,019 in annualized interest.
Verdict: Interactive Brokers is the better choice for investors who regularly borrow against their portfolios. Margin trading can produce losses greater than the amount initially invested.
Trading Platforms: thinkorswim vs. Trader Workstation
Schwab thinkorswim
Thinkorswim is a major reason former TD Ameritrade customers remain with Schwab. The platform is available on desktop, web and mobile. It includes advanced charting, options analysis, paper trading and customizable trading tools. Schwab also provides a dedicated trading desk and physical branch support.
Thinkorswim is well suited to:
- Options chains and strategy analysis
- Technical charting
- Paper trading
- Active stock trading
- Alerts and watchlists
- Learning resources
- Former TD Ameritrade customers who want a familiar platform
Interactive Brokers Trader Workstation
Interactive Brokers Trader Workstation, usually called TWS, is built for investors who want access to multiple markets and detailed trade controls. IBKR supports more than 100 order types and provides API tools for automated or rules-based trading.
TWS is well suited to:
- Multi-market trading
- Complex order types
- Algorithmic execution
- Short-selling tools
- Futures, forex and bonds
- Portfolio and margin analytics
- API and automated trading workflows
Thinkorswim is generally easier to learn. TWS offers more depth, but it takes more setup and product knowledge.
International Investing: Interactive Brokers Wins
Interactive Brokers provides access to stocks, options, futures, currencies, bonds and funds across a large network of global markets. Its individual-investor offering supports trading across more than 170 markets in dozens of countries, with funding and trading in multiple currencies.
Schwab is a strong U.S. brokerage. Interactive Brokers is a better fit if you want to:
- Buy securities listed outside the United States
- Hold multiple currencies
- Trade foreign exchange directly
- Invest across international exchanges
- Manage a globally diversified portfolio from one account
- Access a wider range of futures and fixed-income markets
Choose Interactive Brokers when international market access is a regular requirement rather than an occasional feature.
Fractional Shares
Interactive Brokers supports fractional trading for eligible U.S., Canadian and European stocks and ETFs.
Schwab also supports fractional investing, but its eligible security list is narrower. Interactive Brokers is the stronger choice for investors who want fractional positions across more securities and markets.
Customer Support and Account Experience
Charles Schwab has the stronger service offering. Schwab provides a dedicated trade desk, 24-hour service and hundreds of physical branches.
Interactive Brokers is more self-directed. Its platform focuses on online execution, account controls, funding and reporting rather than branch-based service. Interactive Brokers states that it does not employ human brokers or advisors to manage customer accounts.
Schwab is better if you value human support or in-person assistance. Interactive Brokers is better if you prefer to manage execution, permissions, funding and reporting yourself.
Which Broker Is Better for Retirement Investing?
Charles Schwab is the better fit for most retirement investors.
Schwab combines self-directed brokerage accounts with retirement planning, investment research, financial advice, banking services and branch support. That makes it easier to keep investing, retirement planning and other financial services in one relationship.
Interactive Brokers supports retirement accounts and offers portfolio tools, but its main strength is trading infrastructure rather than an integrated advice and banking relationship.
Which Broker Is Better for Options Trading?
Schwab thinkorswim is easier for most retail options traders, while Interactive Brokers is a better fit for high-volume or technically sophisticated traders.
Choose Schwab thinkorswim if you want:
- Easier options-chain navigation
- Visual strategy analysis
- Paper trading
- Integrated education
- A familiar platform from TD Ameritrade
Choose Interactive Brokers if you want:
- Lower potential commissions at higher volume
- More detailed order controls
- Broad global options access
- Portfolio margin capabilities where eligible
- Advanced execution and API tools
Which Broker Is Better for Day Trading?
Interactive Brokers is better for cost-sensitive, high-volume day traders. Schwab is better for traders who prioritize platform usability and support.
Interactive Brokers has advantages in:
- Margin financing
- Futures commissions
- Global access
- Order routing and execution controls
- Short-sale availability tools
- API connectivity
Schwab has advantages in:
- thinkorswim charting
- Paper trading
- Active-trading education
- Dedicated trade support
- A simpler workflow
Neither broker removes the risks of day trading. Volatility, leverage, execution delays and transaction costs can turn a small price movement into a substantial loss.
Final Verdict
Choose Charles Schwab if you are a former TD Ameritrade customer, a long-term U.S. investor or a trader who wants thinkorswim, paper trading, branch access and human support. Choose Interactive Brokers if you need low-cost margin borrowing, futures trading, international markets, foreign exchange, advanced execution or automated strategies.
| Investor profile | Better choice |
|---|---|
| Buy and hold U.S. stocks and ETFs | Schwab |
| Use thinkorswim or paper trading | Schwab |
| Need branches or human support | Schwab |
| Borrow on margin | Interactive Brokers |
| Trade futures frequently | Interactive Brokers |
| Trade international markets | Interactive Brokers |
| Use APIs or automated strategies | Interactive Brokers |
| Trade options casually | Schwab |
| Trade options at high volume | Interactive Brokers |